Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies – These ultra thick gluten-free dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookies are as delicious as they are impressive!
I’m so glad you’ve been loving our Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Chip Cookies as much as we have! I can’t get enough of the colossal size, but the flavors are even better!
Today I’m back again with another gluten-free Levain style cookie recipe. If you missed it the first time around, let me explain! Levain Bakery is a NYC-based bakery that’s known for their ultra huge (like, 6 oz.!) cookies. They’re 2-3x the size of your average cookie, and the flavor and texture are both outstanding.
They have a small but mighty cookie lineup, that at the moment includes chocolate chip walnut, two chip chocolate chip, dark chocolate chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookies. They’re enormous, but somehow manage to nail the perfect texture–light and delicately crisp on the outside, giving way to a gooey, almost fudgy center that’s absolutely loaded with goodies. Is your mouth watering!?
Levain doesn’t offer gluten-free cookies yet, so we’re making it our mission to tackle them at home. (Because everyone deserves amazing cookies!) This time, we’re making their chocolate peanut butter chip cookies gluten-free. These thick gluten-free chocolate peanut butter chip cookies are packed with peanut butter chips that melt in your mouth and look impressive, to boot.
Best of all, these yummy cookies are SUPER easy to put together. Here’s all you need to get started…
Gluten-Free Levain Cookies, At A Glance:
- Ingredients For Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies
- How To Make Gluten-Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies, Step By Step
- FAQ + Tips And Tricks For The Best Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies
- More Gluten-Free Cookie Recipes To Love
- RECIPE: Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies
Ingredients For Gluten-Free Levain Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies:
- Cool Butter. Since our goal is THICK gluten-free chocolate peanut butter chip cookies, cool (not rock solid cold, not room temperature) butter is extra important. It’ll help keep the cookies from spreading too much during the bake time. I recommend cutting it into cubes to help it cream better.
- Brown Sugar & Sugar. This blend of sweeteners gives the cookies excellent texture and flavor. They’re the perfect balance of moist and chewy and delicately crisp on the outside.
- Room Temperature Eggs. Using room temperature eggs helps them blend into the creamed butter/sugar mixture better. (Here’s a trick for getting eggs to room temperature quickly!)
- Unsweetened Dark Cocoa Powder. Levain uses unsweetened dark cocoa for their cookies, so we are too! I’ll give these cookies and ultra chocolatey look and taste. If dark cocoa isn’t your favorite flavor, you can use 1/4 cup dark cocoa for color and 1/4 cup regular cocoa for flavor. It’s a great sweet spot in the middle!
- Gluten-Free Measure-For-Measure Flour. We highly recommend King Arthur measure for measure gluten-free flour for these cookies. It’s got a great blend of starch and protein, which gives these cookies perfect texture.
- Cornstarch. A “secret” ingredient! Cornstarch keeps the cookies from tasting floury, and helps with their signature texture.
- Salt. More than you might think, but don’t second-guess it! This helps give the cookies a more balanced flavor and offsets the sweetness of both the cookie dough and the peanut butter chips.
- Peanut Butter Chips. Speaking of which, you’ll need peanut butter chips! We recommend Reese’s brand for flavor and texture.
How To Make Gluten-Free Levain-Style Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies, Step By Step:
- Preheat The Oven & Prep Your Pans! Fully preheat the oven to 415 degrees F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper. (You’ll only bake one batch at a time, but you don’t want to put cold dough on a hot baking sheet.)
- Cream The Butter & Sugars. In a stand mixer, cream butter, brown sugar, and sugar 2-3 minutes, or until slightly lighter in color and fluffy. Scrape down the edges of the mixer.
- Add Eggs One At A Time, beating to incorporate after each addition.
- Scrape Down The Edges & Add Your Dry Ingredients. Add cocoa powder, gluten-free flour, cornstarch, and salt. Mix until almost combined, but still powdery.
- Add Peanut Butter Chips and mix until the dough is no longer powdery and the peanut butter chips are fairly evenly distributed.
- Double-Check Your Dough. Use a large spatula to stir through the dough once more to make sure the peanut butter chips are well distributed.
- Measure & Weigh Your Cookie Dough. Use a 2/3 cup to scoop 6-6.2 oz. balls of dough. For best results and most even baking, it is highly recommended that you weigh each cookie dough ball. This might seem fussy, but it’ll ensure that the cookies bake evenly.
- Gently Shape The Dough Balls with your hands. Don’t make them perfectly smooth or pack the dough down tightly. You want to just gently shape.
- Arrange Just 4 Balls Of Dough at a time on a baking sheet, arranging the cookies slightly offset from each other (see the photos or video for an example). Place remaining cookie dough in the refrigerator to keep the butter cold while the first batch bakes. (This prevents the cookies from spreading too much)
- Work One Batch At A Time (Chill The Rest!). Bake the first batch of cookies at 415 degrees for 11-14 minutes, or until the outsides look set but the centers are still molten.
- Cool The Cookies. ALL THE WAY. Allow the cookies to cool on the baking sheet at least 2-3 minutes before transferring to a cooling rack. Cool at LEAST 20-25 minutes on the cooling rack before you break, cut, or bite into the cookies. (If you try to eat or cut them earlier, they’ll still be underdone in the centers!)
- Bake The Second Batch. Repeat the cooking process with the remaining dough, allowing all cookies to cool completely (at least 20-25 minutes) before eating.
- Serve Or Store. Store leftover cookies at room temperature 1-2 days, or store in the freezer up to 6 weeks.
FAQ + Tips And Tricks For The Best Gluten-Free Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies:
Don’t Rush The Cooling Time! Just in case you miss all my emphatic type-shouting everywhere else: PLEASE DON’T RUSH THE COOLING TIME! I love a hot cookie as much as anyone, but with a thick, Levain-style cookie, it’s crucial that you allow the cookies to cool the entire time directed. If you don’t, they’ll be raw in the middle. Friends don’t let friends eat raw cookies!
Weigh The Dough Balls If You Can. The only way to be SURE your cookies are equally sized (especially since we’re not using a cookie scoop or packing down the dough) is to weigh them. An inexpensive kitchen scale makes this easy and will drastically, instantly improve your bakes!
Use High-Quality Peanut Butter Chips. I’m not the most particular about brands for most things, but I really recommend Reese’s peanut butter chips (not sponsored!) for gluten-free Levain dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookies. There are LOTS of peanut butter chips, so the quality matters more than it would otherwise. These ones are the best I’ve tried!
Our Favorite Cocoa Powder. While we’re chatting brands, we love Guittard and Rodelle cocoa powders best for baking. The quality is a cut above and the flavor is *chef’s kiss.* Perfect for making gluten-free chocolate peanut butter chip cookies!
Can I Make These Regular Sized? Yes! I get that not everyone is ready to tackle or serve 8 GIANT cookies. If you’d like to make these more normal sized, you’ll use a large cookie scoop and bake them for 8-10 minutes instead. They won’t take as long to cool 🙂